Here's something that keeps coming up in mom groups and our DMs: nobody's talking about flange sizing until it's too late. Women are out here thinking pumps are just supposed to hurt. Spoiler alert: they're not.
Why Getting Your Flange Size Right Actually Matters
So here's what we keep hearing from moms over and over again: they buy a pump, use whatever size came in the box, and spend weeks thinking they just have "difficult" breasts. Pumping hurts. They barely get any milk. They dread every session.
The reality? In most cases, it's just the wrong flange size.
When the flange doesn't fit properly, you're dealing with nipple pain, sometimes bruising, way less milk than you should be getting, and honestly—pumping just becomes this thing you hate doing. Some moms even develop blocked ducts or mastitis because of poor fit.
But here's what we've learned from countless conversations with mothers: once they figure out their correct size, pumping transforms from painful chore to... well, it's never going to be a spa day, but at least it doesn't hurt anymore.
Can We Talk About This Myth Real Quick?
Okay, biggest misconception that needs to die right now: your breast size has literally nothing to do with your flange size.
After talking to hundreds of moms in our community and across social media, this assumption comes up constantly. So many women think bigger breasts = bigger flanges. Wrong.
Your nipple size is its own thing. We've connected with moms with small breasts who need 24mm flanges, and moms with large breasts who need 17mm. There's zero correlation. Your flange size depends only on your actual nipple diameter—not your cup size, not how much breast tissue you have, not your areola size.
Think about it like shoes. Your height doesn't determine your shoe size, right? Same deal here.
What You Actually Need to Measure
Don't overthink this. You need:
- A printable nipple ruler (most pump brands have them, or just google "nipple ruler printable")
- Maybe a mirror if that helps you see better
- About 5 minutes right after you've pumped or nursed
That last part is important. Nipples swell up during pumping or feeding, so you want to measure when they're at their largest. Just wait like 5-10 minutes after you're done for them to settle back down.
How to Actually Measure (Without Overthinking It)
Step 1: Print the ruler properly
This sounds basic but make sure you print it at actual size—not "fit to page" or whatever your printer defaults to. Most rulers have a test line you can check with a real ruler to make sure it printed right.
Step 2: Line it up
Put the circles on the ruler against your nipple. Just the nipple part, not your areola. You're measuring the part that's actually going to go into the flange tunnel.
Step 3: See what fits
Find which circle your nipple sits in most comfortably. That's your nipple diameter in millimeters.
Step 4: Do some basic math
Take your nipple size and add 2-4mm. That's your flange size.
Like:
- 15mm nipple → try 17-19mm flange
- 20mm nipple → try 22-24mm flange
- 17mm nipple → try 19-21mm flange
You need that extra space because nipples expand a tiny bit when pumping. Too tight and it's rubbing and painful. Too loose and you lose suction.
The COMFY Test (This Has Changed Everything for So Many Moms)
Measuring is just the starting point. Here's how you know if it actually fits right—this feedback comes straight from our community:
C - Centered Your nipple should sit right in the middle of the tunnel. If it's hitting the sides, go bigger.
O - Optimal Movement
Your nipple moves in and out with the suction, but not like, excessively. A little movement is normal. Too much means size down.
M - Minimal Areola Only your nipple goes in the tunnel. If your areola is getting sucked in too, you need a smaller size.
F - Free of Pain This should be obvious but—it shouldn't hurt. No pinching, no burning, no turning white. Pain = wrong fit.
Y - Yield is Good You should see milk within a few minutes and actually empty your breasts. If you're pumping forever and getting nothing, even when you know you have milk, it's probably a sizing issue.
If all five check out? You found your size.
Plot Twist: You Might Need Two Different Sizes
Real talk from the communities we're part of—breasts (and nipples) aren't identical. It's completely normal to need a 19mm on the left side and a 21mm on the right. At first, moms tell us it feels weird, like they're doing something wrong, but it's totally normal.
Also, your size can change. Hormones, how far postpartum you are, whether you're nursing more or less—all of it affects nipple size. What worked in month one might not work in month four. If pumping suddenly gets uncomfortable again, it's time to remeasure.
Why We Designed Our Pumps Differently
After spending time in parenting forums, mom groups, and hearing feedback from our own customers, we kept seeing the same complaints about uncomfortable pumps. That's why we built SilkMum products the way we did.
Our manual pump and wearable electric pump both use soft medical-grade silicone flanges instead of hard plastic. Based on what we've heard from users, it makes such a difference—way less friction, way more comfortable.
We also include multiple flange sizes because the data from across different communities shows one-size-fits-all is a lie. And the suction? It's adjustable and mimics how babies actually nurse, not some torture device setting.
Everything that touches you or your milk is BPA-free because, obviously, that matters.
Whether you want the portability of manual or hands-free electric, the right flange size makes all the difference. We've seen it work for thousands of moms.
When Something Feels Off
Based on the most common issues we see in our support messages and mom communities:
"My nipple is touching the back of the tunnel" Size up. The tunnel needs to be deep enough.
"I have a red ring around my nipple after pumping"
That's friction from a too-small flange. Go bigger.
"My areola is getting pulled in" Go down a size. Only nipple should be in there.
"It used to feel fine but now it hurts" Your size probably changed. Remeasure.
"One side works great, the other side doesn't" Different sizes for each breast. We promise it's fine.
Other Stuff That Actually Helps
Getting your flange size right is huge, but from what we've gathered across different platforms, these things matter too:
Don't crank the suction up to max. More suction doesn't equal more milk. It equals more pain. Start low and increase gradually.
Pump consistently. Your body responds to regular stimulation. Random pumping = confused supply.
Lean forward slightly. Gravity helps. Don't press the flange super hard against your breast—just enough for a seal.
Try to relax. Easier said than done, we know. But stress literally blocks letdown. Look at baby photos, use a warm compress, whatever works.
Massage your breasts. Before and during pumping. It really does help with milk flow.
You Deserve Comfortable Pumping
Here's the thing—pumping is hard enough without adding unnecessary pain to the mix. Moms are already doing so much. The least your equipment can do is actually fit your body.
Taking ten minutes to measure properly and test the COMFY checklist can completely change your pumping experience. From dreading every session to actually being able to pump without thinking about how much it hurts.
Ready to Try Pumps That Actually Fit?
We built SilkMum for moms who are tired of uncomfortable, inefficient pumping:
- Manual Breast Pump - When you need quiet, portable, total control
- Wearable Electric Pump - For actual hands-free pumping that works
- All Our Products - Everything else you need
Still Confused? We're Here
Every mom's situation is different. If you're still not sure about sizing or something just feels wrong, reach out to us at support@silkmum.com or WhatsApp +91 9727270687.
We're not just selling pumps—we're here to help you figure this whole thing out.
Because comfortable pumping shouldn't be a luxury. It should be standard.
Found this helpful? Send it to another mom who's struggling with pumping. Follow us on Instagram for more real talk about breastfeeding.